Extrusion 3D printers, commonly known as Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) printers, are among the most well-known types of 3D printers available in the market. This is due to their versatility and ability to print with a wide range of materials, such as ABS, Nylon, Polypropylene, and PLA. FDM printers are relatively affordable, making them accessible to a wide range of users, from hobbyists to professionals. Their ease of use and accessibility have also made them the most popular choice for educational institutions, design studios, and small businesses.
In this blog post, we will explore the differences between Bowden drive and direct drive FDM technologies.
extrusion components
An FDM 3D printer is a machine that uses a process called extrusion to deposit a material in a precise manner, layer by layer, to create a 3D object. The material is heated and pushed through a small nozzle, which is moved around by the printer's motors to deposit the material in the desired location. The material used in extrusion 3D printing can be a variety of plastics, including ABS and PLA, as well as other materials such as metal.
There are several common parts that make up an extrusion 3D printer, including the extruder, the hotend, and the nozzle. The extruder is responsible for pushing the material through the hotend and nozzle. It typically consists of a motor, gears, and a filament feeding mechanism. The hotend is the component that melts the material and prepares it for extrusion. It typically consists of a heating element and a thermal barrier. The nozzle is the small opening that the material is pushed through. It typically comes in different sizes, and the size of the nozzle will affect the size of the extruded material. The nozzle is also responsible for controlling the flow rate of the material and the precision of the extrusion. These three components work together to ensure that the material is heated and extruded in the right amount and at the right time to create the final 3D object.
bowden drive
In a Bowden drive system, the extruder is separate from the moving parts of the printer and is connected to the hotend via a tube. The motor that drives the extruder is typically located near the base of the printer, while the hotend is mounted on the moving platform.
One of the main advantages of a Bowden 3D printer is that it allows for a lightweight moving platform, which can result in more precise control over the printer's movements. This can lead to a smoother and more consistent extrusion of the material, resulting in a higher quality print.
Also, Bowden drive systems can be less prone to wear and tear than direct drive systems. The extruder is separate from the hotend, making it less exposed to heat. This separation also reduces the mass of the moving parts inside the machine, reducing the mechanical stress on the system.
However, there are some downsides to a Bowden 3D printer as well. Because the extruder is separate from the hotend and connected via a tube, the material must be pushed a longer distance to reach the hotend, which can lead to issues with the material jamming or not being extruded properly. This can result in a less precise and consistent print.
Additionally, Bowden 3D printers are not well suited for printing with flexible materials, because the tube through which the material is pushed can be restrictive and might cause kinking or jamming of the filament, which can be hard to fix.
direct drive
In a direct drive system, the extruder is mounted directly on the hotend, which is also mounted on the printer's moving platform.
One of the main advantages of a direct drive 3D printer is that it allows for more direct control over the extruder. This eliminates the issues that can arise with the material jamming or not being extruded properly, as the material is pushed directly from the extruder to the hotend. This can result in a more precise and consistent print.
Another advantage is that direct drive systems are generally less prone to calibration issues as the extruder and the moving platform are connected. Also, it is well suited for printing with flexible materials, as the direct drive system allows for a more consistent and steady material flow, reducing the chances of kinking or jamming of the filament.
However, there are some downsides to a direct drive 3D printer as well. Because the extruder is mounted directly on the hotend and the moving platform, the moving platform must be heavier to support the extruder and hotend, which can lead to less precise control over the printer's movements. This can result in a less smooth and consistent extrusion of the material, resulting in a lower quality print.
conclusion
Both Bowden drive and direct drive systems have their own advantages and disadvantages when it comes to 3D printing.
Bowden drive systems allow for a lightweight moving platform, which can result in more precise control over the printer's movements and a longer lifespan. However, they are prone to issues with the material jamming or not being extruded properly and require more calibration than direct drive systems.
On the other hand, direct drive systems eliminate the issues that can arise with the material jamming or not being extruded properly and are well suited for printing with flexible materials. However, they have less precise control over the printer's movements and require a heavier moving platform.
Ultimately, the choice between a Bowden drive and a direct drive system will depend on the specific needs and requirements of the user.
Contact us and let us know if this helped!
At Nexus3, we partner with businesses to bring their innovations to life. If you have an engineering challenge that needs solving or if you need parts fabricated using AM technology, contact us. We will help you solve your toughest problems.
- Nexus3 is your innovation partner. Let us help you realize what is possible.
Comments